Bull Case
The best-supported bullish read is a near-term earnings recovery: Q1 EBITDA and operating income improved sharply, Mexico commercial shipments are normalizing after prior destocking, and management explicitly guided to higher Q2 EBITDA. If that guide holds and Pesquería ramps on time, current trading above the immediate post-print close can persist.
Bear Case
The cautious read is that the setup is still mostly a monitoring story: evidence quality in the packet was initially zero, net cash fell to $327 million from $712 million quarter to quarter, working capital absorbed cash, capex remains heavy, Argentina demand is uneven, and part of Q1 net income was helped by a $132 million deferred tax gain while litigation related to Usiminas still created a $48 million loss.