AI Stock Memo: KMX - CarMax - RankAlpha

KMX

Rating neutralAI Memo

CarMax

As of 2026-04-15/Confidence medium

Open ticker Back to Memos

Data freshness

AI Memo

As of 2026-04-15 • Model: RankAlpha Sentiment Codex

Decision Panel

Action, confidence, horizon, and decision blockers at a glance.

Action

neutral

Confidence

medium

Horizon

—

Key catalyst

June 17, 2026 fiscal Q1 report is the first clean checkpoint after the April reset • 2026-06-17

Expected move: -2%

Biggest risk

The latest quarter showed weak comparable demand, lower retail and wholesale gross profit per unit, lower CAF income, a $141.3 million goodwill impairment, and a paused buyback, which together argue the turnaround is not yet proven [#8-K-2026-04-14].

Invalidation

Break below $35 or thesis failure.

What would change my mind?

The stock has already reset sharply after the April 14 result, while CarMax still has national scale, a large sourcing network, strong digital penetration, and a concrete FY27 cost-reduction plan under a newly installed CEO [#8-K-2026-04-14].

Research note

Recommendation

neutral

Confidence

medium

As of

2026-04-15

Base target

$43

p=50%

Bull target

$49

p=25%

Bear target

$35

p=25%

Key bullets

Fast scan of bull, bear, and watch items

BullKey bullets

Early Q1 read-through on whether pricing actions revive demand without another gross-profit giveback
FY27 cost-out and footprint build could rebuild earnings power, but execution burden is high
The stock has already reset sharply after the April 14 result, while CarMax still has national scale, a large sourcing network, strong digital penetration, and a concrete FY27 cost-reduction plan under a newly installed CEO [#8-K-2026-04-14].

BearKey bullets

Activist and proxy-related uncertainty may distract management during an operating reset.
CAF full-spectrum expansion could lift loss provisions faster than financing penetration benefits.
Further used-vehicle pricing pressure could force another retail gross-profit-per-unit step-down.

WatchKey bullets

June 17, 2026 fiscal Q1 report is the first clean checkpoint after the April reset

Summary

High-level snapshot

Recommendation

neutral

Model confidence

medium

Timeframe

Asset

Equity

Trigger

Base case: $43 (p=50%)

Bull/Bear spread: +12% / -20%

Vs latest close: Bull +12% · Base -2% · Bear -20%

Scenario probabilities

Bull Target: $49 (p=25%)Base Target: $43 (p=50%)Bear Target: $35 (p=25%)

Commentary

The setup is cautious-positive but still low-conviction. CarMax delivered a credible cost-out target and has identifiable self-help levers, yet the market reaction to the April 14 release shows investors are focused on declining unit economics and weaker forward visibility rather than the restructuring story. This looks more like a monitoring situation than a clean bullish inflection today.

As of 2026-04-15 • Updated bi-weekly / post-earningsSource: Internal modelMethodology

Analyst Summary

Thesis highlights from the latest analysis

Bull Case

Bear Case

Drivers

Scannable catalysts and supporting factors

Early Q1 read-through on whether pricing actions revive demand without another gross-profit giveback
FY27 cost-out and footprint build could rebuild earnings power, but execution burden is high

Scenarios

Bull Target (Scenario probability)

$49 / p=25% prob

Base Target (Scenario probability)

$43 / p=50% prob

Bear Target (Scenario probability)

$35 / p=25% prob

Price $44 as of 2026-06-02

Nearest Scenario: Base (∆ 2%)

Targets vs latest close: Bull +12% · Base -2% · Bear -20%

Sentiment & Exposure

Sentiment unavailable: insufficient coverage

Events

Other notable items detected

EVENT2026-06-17
June 17, 2026 fiscal Q1 report is the first clean checkpoint after the April reset
CarMax said it plans to report fiscal Q1 results for the quarter ending May 31, 2026 on June 17, 2026. Investors will likely focus on comparable used-unit trends, gross profit per retail unit, CAF provision trends, and whether SG&A per unit starts to improve after restructuring [#8-K-2026-04-14].
Prob 80.00% • Move 10.00% • Priced-in 45.00%

Short-term Catalysts

Next few weeks

Early Q1 read-through on whether pricing actions revive demand without another gross-profit giveback
2026-05-31
Q4 retail used units fell 0.8%, comparable-store used units fell 1.9%, and retail gross profit per used unit dropped $207 to $2,115 as CarMax used pricing actions to improve sales trend; the first weeks of the quarter ending May 31, 2026 are the near-term test of whether volume can recover without further margin erosion [#8-K-2026-04-14].
Prob 60% • Move 6% • Priced-in 70%

Long-term Catalysts

Months to a year

FY27 cost-out and footprint build could rebuild earnings power, but execution burden is high
2027-02-28
Management raised its SG&A reduction target to $200 million in exit-rate savings by the end of fiscal 2027, plans roughly $400 million of FY27 capex, and expects to open four stores, two stand-alone reconditioning/auction centers, and two auction facilities. If the new CEO can pair that program with steadier unit economics, the earnings base could recover; if not, the reset remains mostly a monitoring story [#8-K-2026-04-14].
Prob 55% • Move 18% • Priced-in 30%

Risks

Activist and proxy-related uncertainty may distract management during an operating reset.
CAF full-spectrum expansion could lift loss provisions faster than financing penetration benefits.
Further used-vehicle pricing pressure could force another retail gross-profit-per-unit step-down.
The new CEO transition could take longer to translate into measurable unit, margin, and cost improvement.

Peers

Symbol	Summary
AN	AutoNation is a cleaner execution benchmark with a more diversified dealership model and stronger current profitability, highlighting how far CarMax still has to go on margin recovery.
LAD	Lithia offers a broader mix of new, used, F&I, and service earnings, making CarMax look more exposed to used-vehicle pricing and retail gross-profit volatility.
CVNA	Carvana is the closest scaled used-auto growth comp, but its valuation reflects much stronger unit-growth expectations, underscoring that CarMax is currently being judged on execution repair rather than category leadership.

Sources

Internal and external references used in this analysis

Model source: RankAlpha Sentiment Codex
Analysis date: 2026-04-15